Should I Repair or Replace My Garage Door?

Should I repair or replace my garage door?

If one part has failed, such as a spring, cable, roller or sensor, repair is usually the answer. If panels are badly damaged, the door will not stay aligned or repairs keep coming back, a new door can make more sense.
1A Garage Doors rated 4.9/5
based on 1,017 reviews.

Most garage door problems are a single failed part, and those are repairs. A broken spring, a frayed cable, worn rollers or a misaligned sensor can be fixed without replacing the door. Replacement starts to make sense when the door itself is the problem rather than one of its parts.

Usually a repair

  • A broken torsion or extension spring.
  • A frayed or snapped cable.
  • Noisy or worn rollers and hinges.
  • A door that reverses because of the safety sensors.
  • One damaged section on a door whose panels are still made.

Often a replacement

  • Several sections are badly dented, cracked or rotted.
  • The door will not stay aligned in its tracks even after adjustment.
  • Repairs keep coming back, so you are paying for visits on a door near the end of its life.
  • The panel you need is no longer made, so a repair would not match.

How to find out which way yours leans

Call (916) 838-8182 and describe what happened. We can usually tell you which way it leans before the visit. On site, repair visits carry a $45 diagnostic trip fee and you approve a written price before work starts; if a new door is the better value, the estimate for it is free. For older doors specifically, see whether an old garage door is worth repairing.

Read more

Related questions

Have a different question? Call (916) 838-8182 or browse all garage door questions.

About Us

Contact Us

Office: (916) 838-8182

7534 Westgate Dr ,
Citrus Heights, CA 95610

Why US?

Highly rated garage door experts

  • Warranty on parts and labor

    Repairs and installations carry a warranty on parts and labor.

  • Rated 4.9/5 from 1,017 reviews

    Read what local homeowners say on our reviews page.

  • Written price before work starts

    You approve the price before any repair begins.

  • Major door and opener brands

    Clopay, Amarr, Raynor, Wayne Dalton, LiftMaster, Chamberlain and Genie.

  • Licensed and insured installers

    Licensed, bonded and insured.

1A Garage Doors team

Meet the Team

Licensed garage door technicians

At 1A Garage Doors, excellence is at the core of everything we do. Specializing in garage door installation, repair, tuneups and more.

Get a Quote About 1A

1A Garage Doors on YouTube

Join our community on YouTube and get access to a wide range of videos where we share tips, tricks, and common fixes for garage doors.

Talk to our experts

Clear straightforward pricing

Get Pricing